Blog · Confession

The $1,400 backlink that was a 404 for 3 months

One link, $1,400, deleted in a blog redesign and found 3 months later. Why it happens, what a 404 does to the link, and what to do the day you find it.

The short version

  1. A page you paid to be on can turn into a 404 without anyone telling you. The usual cause is a redesign or a cleanup of old posts.
  2. Google stops using a page that answers 404 or 410, so the link on it stops counting.
  3. The price is lost on day one. What the delay costs is the chance to get a replacement.
  4. Only 404 and 410 mean gone. A 403 or a challenge page is usually a bot wall, not a dead link.

This is the long version of episode 3 of Confessions of a Link Builder, our daily 30-second series. Watch the episode on YouTube, TikTok and Instagram. First the confession, then what is behind it and what to do about it.

The confession

The most expensive 404 I ever saw cost $1,400. One link.

I bought it last year on a big site. The kind you are proud of: real traffic, a relevant article, a clean anchor in the second paragraph. I opened the page the day it went live, saw my link, marked the row "live" in my sheet and moved on to the next deal.

Some time later the owner redesigned the blog. New theme, new structure, and every post older than a year was dropped on the way. Nobody decided to remove my link. Nobody thought about my link at all.

No email. No refund. And it took me 3 months to notice, because nothing in my day ever sent me back to that page. 3 months of a $1,400 link doing nothing, and a row in my sheet that still said "live".

Leo is the AI presenter of the series. His confessions are typical cases of what happens to bought links, told in the first person, and the figures in them are examples.

Why pages you paid to be on disappear

Pages go missing all the time, and almost never because of you. Pew Research Center found that 38% of the webpages that existed in 2013 were no longer available ten years later, and that a quarter of all pages that existed at some point between 2013 and 2023 were gone by October 2023 (When Online Content Disappears, May 2024). In the same report, 23% of news webpages contained at least one broken link.

For links specifically, Ahrefs sampled 2,062,173 websites and found that 66.5% of the links pointing to them since January 2013 had rotted (link rot study). "Not found" was the reason for 4.11% of the lost links, and a redirect for another 5.99%.

The everyday causes behind those numbers:

  • A redesign or a new CMS. The address pattern changes and old posts are not carried over or redirected.
  • A content cleanup. Someone removes thin or old posts to tidy the site. Sponsored posts are easy candidates.
  • A new owner. The site is sold, and the buyer has no record of what the seller agreed with you.
  • An expired domain or hosting. Every link you bought on that site goes at once.

What a 404 does to the link

Google's documentation is plain about it. All 4xx answers except 429 are treated the same: Google's crawlers tell the next system that the content does not exist. Google does not index addresses that return a 4xx status code, and one that was indexed before is removed from the index (How HTTP status codes affect Google's crawlers).

So a 404 and a 410 lead to the same place. The page leaves the index, and the link you paid for leaves with it.

Why it takes months to notice

Nothing about a bought link brings you back to it. You pay once, so no invoice reminds you. You do not read the article again. The seller does not know either: for them it was one of hundreds of old posts.

And the place where you track it lies to you. A sheet that says "live" says what was true on the day you typed it.

What the delay costs

The $1,400 is lost on the day the page goes. The 3 months cost something else: the chance to get it back.

Many sellers will replace a dropped link when you ask soon, with the details in hand. Fewer will after a quarter of a year, when the deal is old and the person who handled it may be gone. If the seller promised a replacement period, it is counted from the day you paid, not from the day you noticed.

You noticeWhat you can still do
The same weekWrite to the seller while the deal is fresh. Ask for the new address or a placement on a similar page.
After 3 monthsAsk anyway, with less to stand on. Any agreed replacement period may be over.
At the yearly auditWrite the money off, and note the seller.

How to check a page in ten seconds

Open the address in your browser, or ask for the status line only:

curl -I https://example.com/the-article/
AnswerWhat it means for your link
200The page is there. Still check that your link is on it.
301 or 302The page moved. Follow it and look for your link on the page you land on.
404 or 410The page is gone.
401, 403, 429 or a challenge pageThe site is blocking the visit. Not proof of anything: look in a browser.
5xxThe server has a problem. Check again tomorrow.

One more case: a page that answers 200 but shows "not found". Google calls that a soft 404 and reports it in Search Console as an error. For your link it is the same as a real one.

What to do the day you find it

  1. Check that the article did not just move. Search the site for its title. If it lives at a new address with your link on it, nothing is lost.
  2. Write to the seller the same day. Give four details: the page, the page it linked to, the anchor, and the date you found it gone. Ask for the article to be restored or for a placement on a similar page.
  3. Write down the outcome. A seller who replaces links is worth more than a cheaper one who does not.

The email template for a deleted page is in how to find lost backlinks and get them back.

By hand, or checked for you

You can open every page you paid to be on once a week. Our free backlink tracker template gives you the list and the money at risk. It is also the kind of job that gets skipped in a busy month.

LinkRot.io opens every link you paid for once a day. Only a 404 or a 410 is reported as "Page is gone", and only after a second look an hour later. Anything else that is not the page, a 403 or a challenge page for example, is shown as unreachable, never as dead. You get the price of what broke and an email with the next step. It does not find links you did not list, and it does not build links. You can check five of your links free, with no signup.

Sources

All figures and quotations were read on the linked pages on 17 November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Does a 404 remove my backlink from Google?

Yes, over time. Google says it does not index addresses that return a 4xx status code, and that an address it already had is removed from the index. A link on a page Google no longer has cannot count for you.

Is a 410 worse than a 404?

Not for this purpose. Google's documentation treats all 4xx answers except 429 the same way: the content does not exist. Both mean the page is gone.

My checker says 403. Is the link dead?

Probably not. A 403, a 401, a 429 or a challenge page usually means the site blocks automated visits. Open the page in your own browser before you write to the seller. Only a 404 or a 410 says the page is gone.

How soon should I notice a dead page?

The same week. The price of the link is lost the day the page goes, but your chance of a replacement depends on what you agreed with the seller and how long ago you paid. The longer you wait, the less you have to stand on.

Can I get a replacement for a link on a deleted page?

Often, when you ask soon and give the details: the page, the page it linked to, the anchor and the date you found it gone. How to find lost backlinks and get them back has an email template for exactly this case.

Reading about it is one look. LinkRot.io looks every day.

It watches every backlink you paid for, emails you the moment one breaks, puts a price on the damage and tells you the next step to get it back. 14-day refund on every plan.